Paper Bag Nativity Craft: A Little Manger and an O Come, All Ye Faithful Book

A meaningful Christmas craft for little hands and big hearts. For moms and teachers alike, this is a sweet way to share the hope and love of Christmas in a Christian classroom, at Sunday school, in your homeschool, or during a cozy afternoon at home.

Mother and two young children enjoying a paper bag Nativity manger and O Come, All Ye Faithful Christmas hymn reader

There is something so sweet about watching little hands tuck baby Jesus into a manger they made themselves. In the middle of all the Christmas excitement, I love having a simple way to slow down, sing together, and help our kiddos remember who we are celebrating. It does not have to be elaborate to be meaningful!

A paper lunch bag, a handful of yellow paper shreds, and the sweetest little baby Jesus. That is the beginning of a Christmas craft I cannot wait for you to make with your kiddos!

This paper bag Nativity craft turns a simple bag into a little manger, complete with a star on top. Pair it with my O Come, All Ye Faithful Nativity Craft and Book for a hands-on way to read, sing, and talk about the first Christmas. Cute, meaningful, and no elaborate supply list required. My kind of Christmas activity!

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Paper bag manger with paper baby Jesus and a star beside the O Come, All Ye Faithful hymn reader
A little manger to make and a Christmas hymn reader to enjoy together.

A little manger they can actually hold

I love a craft that gives children something to do with the story. They can place baby Jesus in the manger, peek through the openings, and hold their finished creation while they sing. It makes a sweet take-home project for a Christian classroom or Sunday School, and it is simple enough to enjoy around the kitchen table, too.

The printable paper baby Jesus keeps the activity easy to prepare for a whole group. You will also see a plush baby in some of my pictures. That is an optional extra, not something you need to purchase to use the craft!

What you will need

  • The star and baby Jesus printables from O Come, All Ye Faithful Nativity Craft and Book
  • A brown paper lunch bag for each child
  • Yellow paper scraps or yellow crinkle paper shreds for the hay
  • Crayons, scissors, and glue
  • A stapler for an adult to use, if you prefer staples to glue at the top
  • Optional: a small plush baby Jesus instead of the paper baby

A quick bag note: An ordinary lunch bag is a good starting point. These larger brown paper bags are another option, but they are 12.5 × 7 × 4.3 inches and come with tin ties, so they are bigger than a standard little lunch sack. Check the fit of your baby and star before preparing a whole class set, and leave the metal ties out of the craft.

Already have yellow construction paper? Cut or tear it into little strips and use that! The hay does not need to be fancy. It is going into a paper bag, not a Christmas decorating competition. Ha!

Paper baby Jesus resting in yellow paper shreds inside a cut paper bag
A little yellow paper makes a cozy-looking bed for the paper baby Jesus.

How to make the paper bag Nativity craft

  1. Color and cut. Let children color the star and baby Jesus, then cut out both pieces. Help younger children with the cutting as needed.
  2. Shape the top of the bag. Cut across the top of the paper bag. I made mine rounded. Keep enough of the top to bring the two sides together later.
  3. Cut the side openings. Cut out the side sections to create the open manger shape shown in the photos. Leave the bottom and the connecting strips of the bag intact so it can still stand and close at the top. This is a helpful step for an adult to prepare for younger children.
  4. Make a little bed. Open the bag and add yellow paper scraps or shreds to the bottom. Place the paper baby Jesus inside. If you are using a plush baby instead, check that it fits comfortably without pulling the bag out of shape.
  5. Add the star. Bring the top edges together and glue or staple the star at the top to close the paper bag manger. An adult should handle the stapler. Let glued pieces dry before children carry their mangers home.

My prep tip: Make one sample before you begin. Set out the paper pieces and a small portion of hay for each child, and have a finished manger nearby to show what the bag will become. A little preparation now means fewer “Where does this go?” moments later!

Now add the O Come, All Ye Faithful book

After making the manger, settle in with the matching Christmas hymn reader. Read it aloud first, look closely at the illustrations, and then sing together. Children can color their pages and follow along with a finger as you read. They do not have to read every word independently to enjoy joining in.

Child points to the O Come, All Ye Faithful reader beside a paper bag manger with a plush baby Jesus
Read, sing, and look at the pictures together. The plush baby is an optional alternative to the printable paper baby.

Pause at the word adore and explain it in little-kid language: to love and worship Jesus. Then let children hold their mangers as they sing. Those little voices and handmade crafts together? So sweet.

Two sweet books to read alongside your craft

Christmas in the Manger

Christmas in the Manger by Nola Buck, illustrated by Felicia Bond is a cute rhyming board book for the littlest listeners. I especially like this one for ages 1–3. Read it before the craft, point out baby Jesus, and talk about what a manger is.

Christmas in the Manger by Nola Buck and Felicia Bond
A short, rhyming read-aloud for your littlest Christmas learners.

Who Is Coming to Our House?

Who Is Coming to Our House? by Joseph Slate, illustrated by Ashley Wolff gives you a sweet animal-centered story to pair with preparing a place for baby Jesus. Ask children how they would get ready to welcome a special visitor, then let them prepare their own little paper bag manger. Treat the animals’ imagined preparations as a storybook telling, rather than details from the Bible.

Who Is Coming to Our House? by Joseph Slate and Ashley Wolff
A sweet companion for talking about welcoming baby Jesus.

A few little conversations that make it meaningful

You do not need a long lesson to make room for a meaningful conversation. Read or retell Luke 2:1–20 in age-appropriate language, then choose one or two questions:

  • Who is the baby in our manger?
  • Where did Mary lay baby Jesus?
  • How do you think the shepherds felt when they heard the good news?
  • If you were going to visit baby Jesus, what gift would you bring?
  • How can we show love to someone today?

At Sunday School: Read the Christmas story, make the manger, and finish by singing together. You could invite each child to share one thing they remember before going home.

At home: Keep the finished manger beside your Christmas books. Let your child choose a book, tell you about the craft, and sing with you. A few quiet minutes count, even in a very busy December.

In a Christian classroom: Spread it over a few short sessions: read and color the book, make the craft, then revisit the story and song. Cutting, coloring, following directions, listening, and talking all have a place here.

Keep it simple, keep it sweet

Use the paper baby, use paper scraps you already have, and let those little handmade details be part of the charm. Pair the manger with O Come, All Ye Faithful Nativity Craft and Book, and your kiddos will have something to make, something to read, and a sweet way to remember who we are celebrating at Christmas.

I hope this brings a little joy to your classroom, Sunday School, or home this Christmas!